An interesting comparison between different scientific knowledge, dedicated to criminal trials in the field of gender-based violence and the prospects for reform of the code discipline, at the center of a heated political debate. This is what was held on Friday 20 March, as part of the II level Master in Medicine and Law, promoted by the Graduate School "Federico Stella" on Criminal Justice (ASGP).
The conference was attended by a large audience, made up of students of the Master's and Criminal Law courses, university professors, doctoral students and lawyers.
The meeting was moderated by Professor Matteo Caputo, Professor of Criminal Law at Università Cattolica, who outlined - in line with the specificities of the Master's Degree in Medicine and Law - the "guidelines" of the interventions, introducing the most important legal aspects and the issues to be addressed during the initiative.
At the opening, Professor Luca Milani, Professor of Developmental and Educational Psychology at Università Cattolica, holder of a course dedicated to the Psychology of gender-based violence, revealed some empirical data that leave us dismayed: according to the latest reports available, one in three women, in the course of their lives, has suffered some form of violence; a statistic that, according to Professor Milani, "has nothing normal", also due to the existence of the "underground" and the "dark field" of violence that is not brought to the attention of the judicial authority. The "invisible" datum of gender-based violence, shown by Professor Milani through the power of an image, also makes us reflect: a tree, with some "visible" branches, to depict the most striking violence (femicides, violence, aggressions), but with the roots that hide other insidious forms of violence (control, denigration, manipulation, blame) and which constitute the first warning signs compared to other more evident and more impactful conducts.
Immediately afterwards, Professor Alain Dell'Osso, Associate Professor of Criminal Law at the Faculty of Medicine and Surgery of the Catholic University, focused on the proposals for reform of the crime punished by art. 609 bis of the Criminal Code. According to Professor Dell'Osso, it is entirely desirable to overcome the current regulatory formulation (centered on the constrictive behavior of the aggressor, which must overcome the active resistance of the victim), but, among the hypotheses under consideration by the legislator, the proposal put forward last January 27, 2026 by the Justice Commission is to be considered preferable, which, unlike the regulatory technique focused on the absence of the free and current consent of the offended person, the crime hinges on the victim's dissent. The reasons lies, above all, in the difficulties of proving, in the criminal trial, the existence of the absence of consent, in the (essential) respect of the bond of beyond reasonable doubt.
Rosaria Stagnaro, Deputy Prosecutor at the Milanese Public Prosecutor's Office, returned her long professional experience in the field of combating the phenomenon of gender-based violence. According to the magistrate, who highlighted the difficulties related to the preliminary investigations and the strengths of the Milanese system, there are, statistically, two major categories of violence: 1) the violence of the unknown perpetrator, which however remains etched in the victim's mind; 2) the violence of the known perpetrator, but with the victim who does not remember anything about the attack, due to the intake of drugs. The second phenomenon would be more frequent and, in the opinion of the rapporteur, generates significant problems in terms of procedural ascertainment, as the Public Prosecutor cannot "count" on the reconstruction of the facts offered by the victim.
The Lawyer of the Court of Milan Francesca Blacks clarified the importance of the role of the lawyer in the protection of victims of gender-based violence. In particular, the presence of a lawyer is essential from the very early stages of the investigation (for example, to supplement a complaint or to provide investigators with documentary support) and, through the establishment of a civil party, ensures the full participation of the injured party in the criminal trial. The lawyer recalled the risks of the so-called secondary victimization and how the victim of gender-based violence often has the fear of not being believed, despite the fact that the jurisprudence, now consolidated, recognizes the full probative value only of the statements made by the offended person, as long as they are intrinsically reliable.
Finally, Mr . Blacks welcomed the legislative provision of the so-called free legal aid for victims of violence, which ensures full legal protection, whatever the overall economic situation of the applicant.
The meeting was concluded by Professor Simone Grassi, Researcher of Forensic Medicine at the University of Florence. The Professor emphasized the importance of the role of the coroner in ascertaining violence: a role that, according to Professor Grassi, in the immediacy of aggression, "is exercised even more with the eyes than with the hands". The analysis also focused on health-related risks (so-called "relative risk"), without neglecting the heavy psychological impact for the victim, related to any anxiety disorders or depressive disorders. Finally, Professor Grassi underlined the danger of using drugs to facilitate violence, since, even from a medico-legal point of view, the amnesia that often accompanies the intake of drugs results in a delay in the professional's checks (and, therefore, a greater difficulty in ascertaining the aggression).
The conference, characterized by a markedly interdisciplinary slant, pursues one of the typical objectives of the Master in Medicine and Law, which, through a mixture of various knowledge, aims to shape high-profile professional figures, capable of moving with awareness in the territories of intersection between medical sciences and forensic sciences.
The Master has already been renewed for a second edition (a.y. 2026/2027) and, shortly, it will be possible to proceed with its registration.