12 October 2026

A story of justice and forgiveness: the lesson of Davide Cavallo

An article by Agostino Picicco | Cattolica News

Can a lesson in criminal law talk about crime, punishment and responsibility starting not from the norm, but from the person who suffered that crime?

This is what happened on Tuesday, October 6, in the Aula Magna of the Catholic University of the Sacred Heart, during the first lesson of the Criminal Law course held by Professor Matteo Caputo. At the center of the meeting, the testimony of Davide Simone Cavallo, a Bocconi student who in October 2025 was attacked and stabbed in Corso Como in Milan, suffering permanent injuries. 
 

Davide's presence was introduced to the students not as that of a "news case" to be analyzed, but as that of a boy like them, with a dramatic story behind him and a choice that goes against the trend of the logic of force and revenge: to continue to recognize a person in the other.
 

On the night of October 12, 2025, Davide was walking in the Corso Como area when he was robbed and attacked by a group of young people. He was kicked, punched and stabbed, suffering a serious spinal cord injury. The subsequent hospital and rehabilitation process radically changed his daily life. The choice not to give in to hatred had already emerged in the letter published by Corriere della Sera last May, written on the eve of the trial. Davide recounted the pain, the new everyday life and the long rehabilitation process, but also the relationship with the boys responsible for the attack. "I don't hate. I should do it, I think, it would be logical, but I can't," he wrote. "I have compassion for them and I hug them."
 

During the lesson, prompted by Professor Caputo's questions, Davide told of his difficulty in performing even the simplest gestures, rehabilitation, the effort of concentrating even on the movement of a leg. "Now I'm standing and that's all that matters," he said, summarizing in one sentence the path taken and the ability to still be happy. "In difficulties come opportunities," he said, taking up a phrase attributed to Albert Einstein. And from his own experience he has drawn a simple conviction: "You have to believe in it, always believe in it and never give up".

The most touching moment of his testimony was the one in which he spoke of the relationship with those who hurt him. The gesture that struck public opinion - the embrace with his attackers - was described by Davide distinguishing the human level from the judicial one. In court, after the delivery of a letter of apology by one of the defendants, he chose to approach them. One of the boys told him, "You could be my brother." He then said that he looked at that hand, the hand of the person who had stabbed him, and accepted it. The hug, in his words, was not a heroic gesture or the cancellation of what had happened. Rather, it was the recognition of a humanity that continued to exist on both sides.
 

It is here that Cavallo's personal story directly meets criminal law. A sentence can establish responsibility and punishment, but it cannot by itself restore what a victim has lost. And forgiveness does not mean denying the crime or erasing the responsibility of those who committed it. Davide experienced this when the twenty-year sentence came for the young man found responsible for the stabbing. The sentence did not give him back what he had lost.
 

It is precisely this aspect that has opened up a question about the meaning of punishment: what does it really mean to do justice when the crime has irreversibly changed a person's life?

Luca Lazzaroni and Giovanni Azzena, the lawyers who assisted Cavallo and his family, also contributed to this question. Their intervention showed how the trial was complex not only from a legal point of view, but also for its human and family repercussions. The crime, in fact, does not only affect the person directly offended but hurts a family balance, involves those close to the victim and, in a broader sense, affects the fabric of society. For this reason, the work of the lawyer cannot ignore the deontological dimension and the ability to listen to people who may have different needs and visions.

Davide told the students that, for a victim, there is perhaps no more healing gesture than being able to talk to the person who committed the crime and return to seeing him as a human being. But he also clarified that there are wounds that no criminal or civil process can erase. He then entrusted the students with a strong phrase: "The real jail, I would like to say to my attackers, is to stay a week with me and see my life now." Words of impact, but which in reality express the request to fully understand the consequences of a gesture, to measure oneself against the suffering caused and with the life that that suffering has changed.
 

A dimension also highlighted by Professor Matteo Caputo since Davide's testimony answered some questions, but raised many others. It will be the following lessons that will try to address them through the tools of criminal law: the meaning of crime, punishment, responsibility, but also forgiveness and restorative justice.
 

The first lesson in Criminal Law, therefore, was not simply the start of a course, but a reflection on the person that the law encounters when a crime occurs. Perhaps it is Davide Cavallo's final warning that encapsulates the profound meaning of the meeting: "Don't be afraid to change things". Even with a hug.