05 December 2024

Restorative justice, the lesson of Balzan Prize winner John Braithwaite

An article by Katia Biondi | Cattolica News

"When I was a child, my grandfather believed in using the cane to gain discipline. My family and my mother were against it. Over time, several empirical analyses have confirmed that they were right: if a parent uses violence against their child, they get less than they expect." It is a simple example, linked to his childhood, the one described by John Braithwaite to reflect on the ineffectiveness of repressive interventions and pave the way for other responses, such as what we now call restorative justice. Professor emeritus at the Australian National University in Canberra and member of the Scientific Council of the Graduate School "Federico Stella" on criminal justice at Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, he has contributed greatly to the theoretical development and global dissemination of restorative justice, so much so that he was awarded the 2024 Balzan Prize, received on Thursday 21 November at the Quirinale by the President of the Republic Sergio Mattarella. "They are just a small cog in a large and complex movement made up of a group of people around the world who carry out scientific research on restorative justice," began the Australian professor who on Monday 25 November was a guest of Università Cattolica to deliver the lecture entitled "Gentle ideas for hard problems: war and peace, crime and justice". An initiative that, promoted by the Graduate School "Federico Stella" on Criminal Justice (ASGP) in collaboration with the Balzan International Foundation, has brought together not only students but numerous professors and scholars in the field interested in listening to one of the "fathers" of restorative justice, author of numerous and important scientific essays, including, to mention the most recent ones,  Simple Solutions to Complex Catastrophes: Dialectics of Peace, Climate, Finance, and Health (London, Palgrave Macmillan, 2024), and Macrocriminology and Freedom (Canberra, ANU Press, 2022).

 

"At a time characterized by general skepticism, also due to the ongoing armed conflicts, restorative justice can be not so much an alternative method of doing justice but a practice to be pursued for the benefit of the community that we need to stem violence, aggression, wars," said Marta Cartabia, president of the General Committee for Prizes of the Balzan International Foundation and professor of Constitutional Law at Bocconi University, to whom goes the credit, with the reform that bears his name, of having given restorative justice in criminal matters an "organic discipline". "This year, the Balzan Foundation wanted to reward Professor Braithwaite for the courage with which he has been conducting his studies for about decades, based on the collection of true stories and concrete acts of solidarity, each of which shows in all its facets the transformative power of restorative justice," continued Cartabia, introducing the lecture together with Cristina Messa, president of the Balzan International Foundation "Prize", and to Gabrio Forti, emeritus of the Catholic University of the Sacred Heart and director of the "Federico Stella" Graduate School of Criminal Justice.

 

Yet, according to Braithwaite, advocates of restorative justice must overcome any "timidity" in affirming its full potential. "Eight meta-analyses have been conducted that from this point of view have statistically significant effects on its ability to reduce crime and war." Positive data that have not yet been sufficient for the full affirmation of restorative justice, just think of how, even  in many democratic countries, incarceration rates remain high. "For this reason, I intend to use the funds received from the Balzan Prize to continue my research in the field, promoting greater dissemination and knowledge of restorative justice. But also by financing scholarships for young people from Africa, certainly among the continents in the world devastated by terrible wars."

 

Once again, it is the stories of real life that come to us to grasp the value of a practice based on mediation, on encounter, on confrontation, even between victim and perpetrator, between those who suffer a wrong and those who commit it. Such as the mobilization of Australian Aboriginal grandmothers, known as "G-Mars", who defend with the power of dialogue the right of their daughters who have become mothers not to be discriminated against in the exercise of parental responsibility on the basis of judgments on parenting skills dominated  by a "white" and Western vision of educational and caring styles. "We must learn from the power of these grandmothers who for years have walked the path of dialogue, applying their lesson everywhere," Braithwaite said. Even the most difficult conflict situations can find seeds of hope in the word and in listening to the other: it is not irenicism. Restorative justice can bear fruit in peace processes: the empirical evidence of the impressive research project entitled "Peacebuilding Compared", which Professor Braithwaite is carrying out with the aim of following all the major armed conflicts in the world until 2030, is clear. They show, for example, the need for capillary, social, interpersonal, bottom-up work, to build and rebuild a vital fabric, in order to prevent populations, especially in countries characterized by strong instability and armed conflicts, from suffering not only from the direct damage of such situations, but also from the effects of broken promises (independence, fundamental rights, equality, human dignity...). Broken promises that offer the right to polarized narratives that, if repeated over time, easily light the fuse of new conflicts or even wars. Because, the Australian scholar recalled, mentioning the concrete case of the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, "threatening nuclear war will not necessarily win against a people committed to defending their freedom at all costs".

 

However, there is still a long way to go for restorative justice and must be intertwined with regulatory models that are themselves innovative. In fact, voluntary compliance with the law is not achieved by deterrence. We need a regulatory mix made up of sanctions and dialogic policies, a mix that Professor Braithwaite calls "responsive regulation": this is where the glimmers of a legal innovation that is still largely to be explored are played.

 

Braithwaite's lecture was followed by a discussion on the themes of the lecture, which was attended, in addition to Marta Cartabia, by some of the leading scholars in Italy of restorative justice, such as Ivo Aertsen, emeritus of Criminology at the Leuven Institute of Criminology, KU-Leuven, Belgium, Adolfo Ceretti, professor of Crimonology at the University of Milano-Bicocca,  Gian Luigi Gatta, Professor of Criminal Law at the University of Milan, and Claudia Mazzucato, Professor of Criminal Law at the Catholic University of the Sacred Heart.