28 March 2023

The ethical strength of literature against the return of torture

An article by Katia Biondi | Cattolica News

There are many international norms that prohibit torture or any other inhuman or degrading treatment. The "eternal" prohibition of torture established in the German legal system or Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which also indicates it as the only inalienable right, are the most evident manifestation of this. However, the enormous arsenal of provisions against the violence exercised by power has not been enough to silence the animated debate on the "legitimization or re-legitimization of torture" that has taken place during the twenty-first century, even in worlds we could not imagine.
 

Drawing attention to the emergence of a "new apologetics of torture" was Gabriele Fornasari, Professor of Criminal Law at the University of Trento where he also directs the Observatory on Peace, Conciliatory and Restorative Justice. And he did so on Thursday 9 March during the third meeting of the seminar cycle "Justice and literature", now in its thirteenth edition, and dedicated to analyzing violence in its various facets: individual, institutional, verbal. A multi-voiced reflection on a theme that has returned to the fore, especially in the aftermath of September 11, 2001, and which has developed around the analysis of two literary works: "In the Penal Colony" by Franz Kafka, written in 1914, and "Waiting for the Barbarians" by John Maxwell Coetzee, published in 1980, distant in time but united by the same representation of bodily torture.
 

"Waiting for the Barbarians", whose title is taken from a poem by Konstantinos Kavafis, is a short novel, consisting of six chapters narrated in the first person by an anonymous voice. It is a story steeped in philosophy, deeply conceptual and allegorical. Where "allegorism" takes on a precise role, and "is used to interpret central issues: power, the devastation of human dignity wrought through torture and the relationship of the lawman with the fallibility of the law itself with respect to the ideal of justice", explained Roberta Gefter Wondrich, professor of English Literature at the University of Trieste, and one of the discussants of the meeting "The body tortured by power: from Kafka's Penal Colony to Coetzee's Waiting for the Barbarians ", introduced by Gabrio Forti, director of the Graduate School "Federico Stella" on Criminal Justice (ASGP).
 

According to Professor Gefter Wondrich, the extraordinary nature of Coetzee's work lies precisely in its "exploring the moral connivance of the lawman with the deviances of power". But also in the "representation of torture in which the body, with its pain and its signs, becomes a sort of literary text". After all, it is precisely in the intertwining of body, pain and graphic sign imprinted in the flesh that the link with Kafka can be grasped. It is no coincidence that Coetzee, who is his greatest heir among the authors of contemporary literature, is a writer who invites us to reflect on the fact that literature is an event precisely because it has an "essential ethical dimension". In fact, all his work is focused on the responsibility of writing, which can thus be an ethical response to the collapse of the meaning found in the experience of abuse, power, and the destruction of the dignity of the human being.

For this reason, "Waiting for the Barbarians" fits perfectly "into that open space of literature 'before the law'" and represents "with great force the potential, the capacity with which the sphere of law and the law places the literary narrative in front of a request for involvement and ethical positioning that passes from the author to the reader and that extends from him to the many". A request, specified the professor of the University of Trieste, "which is also placed in the face of an understanding and dramatization of the complexity of human action in the rule of law and its subversions, in the dynamics of power, in its exclusions and involutions of subjects and which, therefore, refers to an ethical and political discourse that can be expressed precisely in that space of indeterminacy and multiplicity that is the essential dimension of literature".

 

The ethical meaning, but not only. For Professor Fornasari, "Coetzee's work, with the typical strength of the artist, opens the mind to the aberration of what I have called neo-justificationism or rather the new apologetics of torture" and which even finds in Niklas Luhmann, one of the most important sociologists of law of the late twentieth century, one of its most influential intellectuals. Now, according to Fornasari, what is lacking in torture is above all the recognition of the dignity of the other. In fact, the torturer is trained, even before handling instruments for the torture of the body, to identify in the other person a subject who does not deserve dignity. Torture is not just an act, it does not only make the victim lose control of the body and psyche but trust in the world. The tortured person sees himself transformed into an object, into an entity no longer endowed with personality and unable to count on solidarity. For his part, the torturer, as well described by Coetzee, is characterized by "a deadly, tremendous mixture of insecurity and omnipotence".
 

A risky debate, the one around the possible justifications of torture, given that even the supporters of the same point out as always 'extreme', as the beginning of an inclined plane into which one can easily fall and then end up justifying torture tout court . Hence the formidable lesson that the South African author gives to the jurist. "As only the artist can do admirably and not the one who writes the laws for a living, 'Waiting for the Barbarians' combines both arguments that condemn torture: the philosophical and a priori one, which qualifies it as a taboo, and the legal-political one, which identifies in it the most dangerous attack on the cardinal principle of the protection of human dignity".
 

An aspect, that relating to the writing of laws, also taken up by Professor Gabrio Forti, who provided some hypotheses for reading, with criminal reverberations, of Kafka's enigmatic story "In the penal colony", which is also the first literary treatment of torture described in detail. On the other hand, when the jurist writes the laws, to use an expression of the German playwright Friedrich Hebbel, it is as if he were "dipping his pen in blood". That is, even "the jurist at certain times feels the perception of how that norm has been formulated in such a way as to grasp essentially the human that is at stake". And that, therefore, writing the law means "thinking about the body and blood of the people, of the human beings who are involved, of the victim, for example, of the one who is technically the owner of the legal asset or of the person in flesh and blood who directly or indirectly suffers the consequences of the fact," Professor Forti clarified. It is no coincidence that the good legislator in ancient times was often a poet who knew how to "imagine", "because the good law is the one that lasts over time and therefore with the same imagination of the man of letters and the poet he manages to transfuse into the words of the law worlds and humanity that are not before our eyes".