23 July 2022

The Parthenon Marbles: Law or Justice?

An article by Arianna Visconti | Life and Thought

Recently there has been renewed talk of a possible return to Greece of the Parthenon friezes housed in the British Museum since 1816. The enthusiasm aroused by the announcement of the imminent start of negotiations in front of the special UNESCO Commission (Intergovernmental Committee for Promoting the Return of Cultural Property to its Countries of Origin or its Restitution in case of Illicit Appropriation, ICPRCP) was moreover immediately chilled by the denial that came, in a short time, from the British delegation to this body.
 

An outcome that is not at all unexpected, at least for those who have followed the story over the last decades, studded with recurring requests for negotiations by Greece, always rejected by the United Kingdom government. Nor do the arguments and reshuffles of responsibility re-proposed on this occasion sound new. On the one hand, the British representatives argued that the decision on the fate of the marbles, including any negotiations with the Greek government, is the exclusive responsibility of the trustees of the British Museum, as an autonomous body in the choices concerning the museum collections; on the other hand, the Board of Trustees itself has repeatedly reiterated that it does not have the power to dispose of any asset in the museum's collections, since any restitution would require a special act of Parliament. Added to this is the recurring reference to the full legality of the acquisition of the sculptures. All strictly true – as far as it goes .
 

The history of the friezes
The friezes of the Parthenon were in fact given to Lord Elgin, British ambassador to the Sublime Porte, by the authority legally in charge at the time, and later acquired to the collections of the British Museum with a special legislative act.
 And it is the British legislation in force that binds the museum's collections, and identifies the aforementioned trustees as an independent body responsible for their management. Similarly, from a strictly legal point of view, none of the main conventions adopted in the twentieth century to protect the integrity of the national cultural heritage of the contracting states (the 1970 UNESCO Convention and the 1995 UNIDROIT Convention, the latter never ratified by the United Kingdom) can help in settling the dispute, due to the operation of the principle of non-retroactivity.

In this sense, the case of the Parthenon marbles has become emblematic of the multiple instances in which what is 'legal' and what is 'just' end up being in open opposition, particularly in relation to delicate questions of belonging and accessibility of important components of the material and spiritual heritage of a people.

Digging just below the surface, in fact, we can see how the epochal decision to cede to a foreign subject this fundamental testimony of the history and heritage of classical Greece was taken by an occupying power, the Ottoman Empire, totally indifferent to the protection of this heritage and, indeed, fundamentally interested in suppressing any expression of an autonomous Greek national identity (so much so as to be disinterested in the methods of the 'levy' which, in fact, it did not only affect the friezes already detached from the pediment, but involved the removal of many elements that are still intact). Already at the time there was no shortage of those, such as Lord Byron, who denounced the operation as an unjustifiable act of vandalism and looting. In the same years, moreover, Antonio Canova completed the recovery (of a large part) of the works looted in Italy during the Napoleonic campaigns, on the basis of the principle, proclaimed by Quatremère de Quincy as early as the end of the eighteenth century, according to which the separation of an element of cultural heritage from its context of origin represents a serious wound to the universal value of that same heritage. A principle that would later be codified not only in the treaties already mentioned, but even before that in the international law of armed conflict, starting with the 1954 Hague Convention and its Protocols.
 

A fair and just solution
All elements that should push, today, the British government and the British Museum to reconsider the opportunity to start (jointly) serious negotiations with the Greek authorities in view of a reasonable, fair and 'just' solution to this very long dispute
 – a solution that could, and probably should, imply 'creative' choices of co-ownership of the friezes, relocation and replication of some of them, and so on. Some positive signs in this sense – such as the recent opening of George Osborne, president of the British Museum – exist, also thanks to a broader debate on the theme of the restitution of appropriate cultural property in the era of colonial rule, to which the situation of Greece at the beginning of the nineteenth century is ultimately assimilable.

A debate that sees this same institution – not surprisingly renamed by Dan Hicks, in a recent highly successful essay, 'Brutish Museum' – increasingly isolated and criticized in its (de facto) 'retentionist' position (where the accusation of cultural retentionism is typically leveled at countries that are victims of dispossession and therefore supporters of a protectionist policy of their cultural heritage), traditionally masked under the flaunted ideal of a (misunderstood) 'cultural universalism' that the great museums (obviously Western) would embody and defend. A debate that should, moreover, also question Italy, too often focused only on its own (undoubtedly legitimate and real) interests as an 'involuntary exporter' of antiquities and works of art, and unfortunately forgets, instead, the heavy legacy of its own, short but bloody, colonial past.