2024
Causality and determinacy in criminally relevant psychic interactions
It has been said that psychic causality is a sort of "window on the metatheoretical nature of criminal law, the relevance of which scholars and practitioners normally tend to obscure, while sometimes making unconscious use of it". Among the many questions that the theme of criminally relevant psychic interactions raises, those related to the nature and empirical verifiability of the link between communicative behaviors lato sensu and the effect that they produce in the inner sphere of the recipient, often conditioning their behavior, take on pre-eminent interest. Any investigation on the subject must therefore deal with the principle of determination, not surprisingly deepened – in its dual substantial and procedural dimension – in a ruling of the Constitutional Court that had as its object precisely a dynamic of psychic influence, the historic sentence on the crime of plagiarism. Having examined the orientations that have emerged within the Italian doctrine, also in the light of the German and Anglo-Saxon dogmatic elaboration, this work proposes a reinterpretation of the model of causal ascertainment outlined by the French United Sections aimed at demonstrating, mutatis mutandis, its usability in the sector under analysis. It is in this perspective that we dwell both on the role of the principles of self-responsibility and self-protection and on the epistemological status of the human sciences, maxims of experience and indicators, coming to formulate a series of recommendations for a profitable and balanced judicial use of these parameters. Finally, the landings reached become the 'lenses' to focus on some criminal hypotheses with a final or intermediate psychic event, including the so-called mental manipulations, persecutory acts, torture, moral complicity in the crime, corruption cases, fraud and instigation to suicide, taking into account the digital evolution of the related modes of conduct. The result of the examination, enriched by comparative ideas, is the identification of some 'usurping variables' to which the legislator and the judge must pay attention when it comes to, respectively, typify and interpret the various forms of psychic conditioning that can offend legal goods worthy of protection.
More information
Series: STUDIES | 3
Pages: 768
Place and year of publication: Turin, 2024
ISBN: 9791221108132