From 01 January 2018 Until to 31 December 2021

The criminal liability of air traffic controllers

Year
2018-2021

Scientific Direction
Gabrio FORTI

Research Team
Matteo CAPUTO
Francesco D'ALESSANDRO
Eliana GRECO
 

Foreword

The criminal response to major disasters, including aviators, represents one of the most significant issues of modernity and requires a multidisciplinary analysis that is able to grasp and adequately enhance – especially in the mechanisms  of judicial ascertainment of responsibility in the face of major adverse events – the complex organizational reality, the dense fabric of intersubjective relationships and the changeability of the risks that operators are called upon to govern within "systems with complex interaction and close connection".
 

The intensification of air traffic is accompanied, in fact, by the need for a capillary coordination activity, functional to ensure that "rapid, orderly and safe flow" of transits in the controlled and uncontrolled flight spaces that represents the primary purpose of the profession of air traffic controller (ATC) and which requires the use of high standards of diligence, qualitatively enhanced by the necessary use of Non-Technical Skills (NTS) – significantly included among the evaluation parameters during the periodic verification of the ATC's skills – i.e. by "personal and social cognitive skills that are added to the technical skills of operators and professionals" and which, in the field of air traffic, 'refer, in particular, to the transversal skills of the profession such as decision-making skills, problem-solving, situational awareness', both individual and collective, as well as 'communication and the ability to work in a team'.
 

In the face of these preliminary findings, the Graduate School "Federico Stella" on Criminal Justice (ASGP) and ANACNA (National Association of Air Navigation Assistants and Controllers) conducted, in the years 2019-2020, a research that aims to enhance, in the ascription of any adverse facts, the peculiarities of the organizational context and the specificity of the risks that characterize the management of the air navigation, so that we do not incur, as has often happened, in the "trap" of the scapegoat.

Research objectives

More specifically, the research is aimed at analyzing the mechanisms of imputation of the event due to fault in High Reliability Organizations, i.e., in "organizations" that operate in "highly complex environments while maintaining high standards of reliability and safety, on the one hand, and effectiveness and efficiency, on the other". 

By qualifying air navigation as an area pertaining to the area of permitted risk, an attempt has been made to bring to light the peculiarities that characterize the profession of air traffic controller and, precisely, the management of aeronautical risk, so that they are the subject of attention in order to develop rational, effective and concretely implementable regulatory solutions, as they are suitable for:  

  • reduce the impact on the air navigation system of the so-called 'accusatory approach to error', which inhibits learning dynamics from situations of poor threat management and favours the adoption of defensive attitudes by operators;
  • limit the risk – extremely present in sectors with high harmful potential – of overcriminalization, identifying not only good practices, but also procedural models and prospects for regulatory innovation. 

The research concluded, in fact, with a proposal for a regulatory articulation, in the awareness that the analysis of the dynamics of imputation due to large-scale harmful events presents not only a legal, but also a social, cultural and operational interest, representing a paradigmatic framework for a more general rethinking of the criteria for imputing the negligent act. 

The method

The research followed an interdisciplinary methodology . Sociological and criminological acquisitions have been accompanied by the study of criminal law relating to related sectors (the medical one, first of all), constantly taking into consideration the indications coming from international and European law.
 

The Project was structured as a practice-based study: in fact, an empirical investigation was launched, through interviews – initially qualitative – with the valuable collaboration of many ANACNA representatives, aimed at acquiring knowledge about the context within which the air traffic controller operates and according to which procedures. The interviews, mostly carried out in the form of focus groups, aimed to collect data on the methods of conduct of operators both in ordinary contexts (absence of threats, errors, undesirable states), and in contexts of proximity to adverse events.  

The qualitative interviews were accompanied by a quantitative survey , in which 169 air traffic controllers participated  , with different roles (ATCos, tower controllers, room managers, FISO operators) and belonging to different age groups.

Sample question and answer

The phases of the research

The research was divided into the following phases:

  • Phase 1: carrying out the quantitative and qualitative empirical investigation;
  • Phase 2: analysis and coding of the data emerging from empirical investigations;
  • Phase 3: "in the field" research and visit to the radar room of Milan-Linate airport and further interviews with the operators present;
  • Phase 3: analysis and cataloguing of the relevant literature;
  • Phase 4: case study (identification of a particularly relevant case of aeronautical accident and analysis of the same, from a legal, criminal, sociological and organizational point of view);
  • Phase 5: drafting of a final paper and regulatory proposals.

The output of the research

The research led to the development of a proposal to regulate the liability profiles of the air traffic controller.
The results of the research will be included in one or more publications (collective volume and journal article), also in English, and will be presented at two study conferences, which will be attended not only by jurists, but also by organizational psychologists, sociologists, members of ANACNA and ENAC, and representatives of the judiciary.